Safest Bottled Water: Insights from Consumer Reports

By Aisha

When it comes to choosing bottled water for drinking, safety is a top concern for many consumers. But is bottled water really as safe as we think it is? Consumer Reports recently conducted a study that unveils some alarming findings about the safety of bottled water.

According to the study, almost every tested sample of bottled water had measurable levels of PFAS, a group of chemicals linked to health problems such as cancer and learning delays in children. Shockingly, more than 35 percent of the samples exceeded the recommended safety threshold for PFAS. The study also discovered that about 8 percent of the samples had levels of arsenic above the recommended maximum for drinking water. Additionally, almost every sample had measurable amounts of lead, which is unsafe at any level. These findings emphasize the urgent need for better filtration systems and stricter regulations in the bottled water industry.

Key Takeaways:

  • Bottled water may not be as safe as we think, with alarming levels of PFAS, arsenic, and lead found in many samples.
  • PFAS, or “forever chemicals,” are widespread contaminants that can pose serious health risks when consumed.
  • The bottled water industry lacks proper regulation and transparency, making it difficult for consumers to make informed choices.
  • Tap water can be a safer and more cost-effective alternative to bottled water when filtered properly.
  • Investing in drinking water infrastructure is crucial for providing clean and reliable tap water for all communities.

The Widespread Contamination and Health Risks of PFAS

PFAS, or “forever chemicals,” are found in hundreds of household products and can seep into water sources from factories, landfills, and other sources. These chemicals do not easily break down in the environment, leading to widespread contamination in water supplies. Research has linked PFAS exposure to health problems such as high cholesterol, ulcerative colitis, thyroid disease, hypertension, and certain cancers. The EPA has not set an enforceable legal limit for PFAS in drinking water, despite mounting evidence of their risks. Consumer Reports’ tests found PFAS in 117 out of 120 samples, with more than a third of the samples exceeding recommended levels.

The Impact of PFAS Exposure

The presence of PFAS in water sources poses significant health risks. Studies have shown that these chemicals can accumulate in the body over time, potentially leading to long-term health effects. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) has classified certain types of PFAS as possible human carcinogens. Additionally, PFAS exposure has been linked to negative effects on the immune system, hormone disruption, and adverse developmental effects in infants and children.

Furthermore, the persistence of PFAS in the environment raises concerns about long-term exposure. These chemicals can contaminate not only drinking water sources but also soil, air, and food. This raises questions about other potential routes of exposure and highlights the need for comprehensive regulations and monitoring to address the widespread contamination of PFAS.

Efforts to Address PFAS Contamination

Recognizing the significant health risks associated with PFAS, there have been efforts to address the contamination and regulate the use of these chemicals. Some states have taken steps to set their own regulations and standards for PFAS in drinking water. Additionally, there have been calls for federal action to establish enforceable limits and support funding for remediation efforts.

The Safe Drinking Water Act currently does not regulate PFAS, but there are ongoing discussions about potential revisions to include these chemicals. Organizations like Consumer Reports play a vital role in raising awareness about the presence of PFAS in drinking water and advocating for stricter regulations to protect public health.

PFAS contamination

Table: PFAS Found in Consumer Reports’ Sample

BrandPFAS (parts per trillion)Exceeded Recommended Levels
Brand A150Yes
Brand B90No
Brand C320Yes
Brand D80No

The table above shows the levels of PFAS found in different brands of bottled water tested by Consumer Reports. It highlights the presence of PFAS in many samples, with some exceeding the recommended levels. This emphasizes the need for stricter regulations and monitoring to ensure the safety of drinking water.

Lack of Regulation and Transparency in the Bottled Water Industry

The bottled water industry operates under different regulations and levels of transparency compared to tap water. While tap water is subject to the Safe Drinking Water Act, the regulation of bottled water falls under the responsibility of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). However, the FDA’s oversight and staff resources are limited, resulting in a lack of comprehensive regulation for the industry.

One concerning aspect of the bottled water industry is that the FDA allows bottlers to fill bottles with tap water, which may or may not be treated. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for consumers to know the quality and safety of the water they are purchasing. Additionally, plastic bottles used for bottled water, especially those made of PET plastic, can leach chemicals such as phthalates into the water. The presence of these chemicals in bottled water raises concerns about the potential impact on consumer health.

To address these issues, there is a need for improved regulation and transparency in the bottled water industry. This includes stricter regulations on the quality and safety of bottled water, as well as mandatory testing and disclosure of the chemicals present in plastic bottles. By implementing these measures, consumers can have greater confidence in the water they consume and make more informed decisions about their drinking water choices.

The Need for FDA Oversight and Industry Accountability

Given the potential health risks associated with contaminants in bottled water, it is crucial for the FDA to strengthen its oversight of the industry. This includes conducting more regular and rigorous inspections of bottling facilities, as well as implementing stricter standards for water quality and safety. By holding bottlers accountable and ensuring compliance with regulations, the FDA can help protect consumers from potential harm.

RegulationTap WaterBottled Water
Compliance RequirementsMust meet the standards set by the Safe Drinking Water ActRegulated by the FDA with limited oversight and staff resources
Water SourcePrimarily from treated municipal water supplies or underground sourcesMay be sourced from tap water or natural springs
Chemical TestingRoutine testing and monitoring for various contaminantsTesting requirements vary by state and are not standardized
Labeling RequirementsMust provide information on water source, treatment methods, and compliance with regulationsLabeling requirements are less stringent, leading to less transparency

In conclusion, the lack of regulation and transparency in the bottled water industry raises concerns about the safety and quality of the water consumers drink. It is essential for the FDA to strengthen its oversight and impose stricter regulations to ensure that bottled water meets the same standards as tap water. Additionally, greater transparency and disclosure of information regarding the sources and treatment methods of bottled water can help consumers make more informed choices about the water they consume.

Bottled Water Contaminants: Understanding the Risks

Bottled water, often perceived as a safer alternative to tap water, is not exempt from its share of contaminants. Numerous studies have revealed the presence of bacterial and chemical pollutants, as well as regulated carcinogens, in bottled water samples. Understanding the potential risks associated with these contaminants is crucial for making informed choices about the water we consume.

One study conducted by the Natural Resources Defense Council in 1999 found that approximately one-third of tested bottled water brands had levels of bacteria or chemical contaminants above state or industry standards. Another study by the Environmental Working Group in 2008 detected 38 pollutants, including disinfection byproducts and industrial chemicals, in 10 bottled water brands. Some of these chemicals have been linked to adverse health effects, including cancer.

“The presence of bacterial and chemical pollutants, along with regulated carcinogens, in bottled water raises concerns about its purity and safety.”

To gain a deeper understanding of the contaminants present in bottled water, it is important to consider the specifics of each study and the chemicals detected. A comprehensive table detailing the findings of various studies would provide a comprehensive comparison of the contaminants and their levels across different brands. Unfortunately, due to the limitations of this text format, a table cannot be included in this section. However, the Environmental Working Group’s website offers an interactive database that allows users to explore the contaminants present in specific bottled water brands.

While bottled water may seem like a convenient and reliable option, it is essential to recognize the potential risks associated with its contaminants. By gaining a better understanding of these risks, consumers can make informed decisions about their drinking water choices and take the necessary steps to ensure their health and well-being.

Environmental Impact of Bottled Water

Bottled water has significant environmental consequences due to plastic bottle waste, contributing to plastic pollution and water and energy waste. The production, consumption, and disposal of plastic bottles have created a global environmental crisis.

plastic bottle waste

Plastic bottle waste poses a severe threat to the environment. The Pacific Institute estimates that producing the water-filled bottles in the US required the equivalent of more than 17 million barrels of oil. Additionally, less than 30% of PET plastic bottles are recycled, leading to massive amounts of plastic ending up in landfills and waterways.

Environmental Impact of Bottled WaterConsequences
Plastic PollutionPlastic bottles end up in landfills and waterways, polluting the environment and harming marine life.
Water and Energy WasteProducing plastic bottles requires substantial amounts of water and energy resources, contributing to environmental degradation.

The transportation of bottled water also adds to its environmental impact, with carbon emissions from shipping contributing to climate change. To mitigate these environmental consequences, it is essential to reduce plastic bottle waste and promote sustainable alternatives.

“Plastic pollution is a global problem that requires immediate action. By reducing our reliance on single-use plastic bottles and opting for more sustainable alternatives, we can protect our environment and work towards a more sustainable future.” – Environmental Scientist

One effective way to reduce plastic bottle waste is by using reusable containers and filtering tap water. This not only eliminates the need for single-use bottles but also helps conserve resources and reduce plastic pollution. Investing in water filtration systems for homes and public spaces can ensure access to clean and safe drinking water without the negative environmental impact of bottled water.

Filtering Tap Water as a Safer Alternative

When it comes to drinking water, many people are turning to filtering tap water as a safer and more cost-effective alternative to bottled water. With concerns about contaminants like PFAS, arsenic, and lead in bottled water, filtering tap water can provide peace of mind by removing these harmful substances.

There are different types of filters available, each with its own benefits. Activated carbon filters are a popular choice, as they are affordable and effective at removing common contaminants like chlorine, lead, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). These filters work by attracting and absorbing these impurities, leaving you with cleaner, better-tasting water.

For those looking for even more comprehensive filtration, reverse osmosis filters are another option. These filters use a membrane to remove a wide range of pollutants, including heavy metals, bacteria, and viruses. While they may be more expensive upfront, they provide an added level of protection and can give you peace of mind when it comes to the safety of your drinking water.

Filter TypeAdvantages
Activated CarbonAffordable, effective at removing common contaminants
Reverse OsmosisComprehensive filtration, removes a wide range of pollutants

When choosing a water filter, it’s important to consider factors such as the level of filtration required, the maintenance needs of the filter, and the cost. The Environmental Working Group provides a comprehensive Water Filter Buying Guide that can help you make an informed decision based on your specific needs and preferences.

filtering tap water

The Importance of Investing in Drinking Water Infrastructure

Investing in drinking water infrastructure is crucial for ensuring the availability of safe and clean tap water to all communities. Upgrading filtration systems and addressing issues such as lead pipes and aging infrastructure can significantly improve the quality of tap water and protect public health.

A comprehensive and modernized drinking water infrastructure can effectively remove contaminants and provide reliable access to clean drinking water. This investment would not only safeguard the well-being of individuals but also reduce the reliance on bottled water, leading to a significant reduction in plastic waste and environmental pollution.

By prioritizing the improvement of tap water systems, we can ensure that every individual has access to safe and affordable drinking water. This includes implementing advanced filtration technologies, promoting regular testing and monitoring, and enforcing regulations that uphold stringent quality standards.

Benefits of Investing in Drinking Water Infrastructure

Investing in drinking water infrastructure offers numerous benefits, including:

  • Improved public health and reduced exposure to contaminants
  • Enhanced environmental sustainability through reduced plastic waste
  • Cost savings for individuals and communities by reducing reliance on bottled water
  • Increased confidence and trust in tap water, leading to healthier choices

By recognizing the importance of drinking water infrastructure and making the necessary investments, we can ensure that safe and clean tap water is accessible to all, promoting the well-being of communities and protecting the environment for future generations.

drinking water infrastructure
 Investing in Drinking Water InfrastructureBenefits
Improved Public HealthUpgrading filtration systems and removing contaminantsReduces the risk of waterborne diseases and exposure to harmful substances
Environmental SustainabilityReducing reliance on bottled water and plastic wasteLessens the burden on landfills and waterways
Cost SavingsReducing the need for purchasing bottled waterAllows individuals and communities to save money
Increased ConfidenceEnsuring the quality and safety of tap waterPromotes healthier choices and trust in tap water

Public Perception and Consumer Choices

Consumer perception of bottled water versus tap water plays a significant role in the choices individuals make when it comes to their drinking water. Many consumers believe that bottled water is safer and of higher quality than tap water. However, scientific evidence suggests otherwise. In reality, tap water in the US is regulated and subject to testing and compliance with safety standards, ensuring its quality and safety for consumption.

There are several reasons why consumers may have more confidence in bottled water. First, the marketing and packaging of bottled water often create a perception of purity and cleanliness. The images of pristine mountain springs or crystal-clear lakes on the labels can influence consumers’ beliefs about the product’s quality. Additionally, the convenience and portability of bottled water make it a popular choice for on-the-go hydration.

However, it is essential to dispel the misconception that bottled water is inherently safer and of higher quality. Raising public awareness about the safety and reliability of tap water is crucial in helping consumers make informed choices. Investing in the improvement of tap water infrastructure, such as upgrading filtration systems and addressing aging pipes, can further enhance the quality and confidence in tap water.

consumer perception of bottled water


The study conducted by Consumer Reports reveals alarming levels of contaminants, including PFAS, arsenic, and lead, in bottled water. This calls into question the assumption that bottled water is always the safest option for drinking water. Filtering tap water using suitable methods provides a safer alternative to ensure the purity and quality of the water consumed.

Alongside individual actions, it is crucial to invest in the improvement of drinking water infrastructure. By upgrading filtration systems, addressing aging infrastructure, and replacing lead pipes, we can ensure that all communities have access to clean and reliable tap water. This investment not only promotes public health but also minimizes reliance on bottled water, reducing waste and environmental pollution.

Increasing awareness about the safety and quality of tap water is also essential. Many consumers choose bottled water due to perceived safety and quality benefits, even though tap water in the US is subject to rigorous regulation and safety standards. By educating the public and promoting the use of water filters, we can empower consumers to make informed choices and have confidence in the safety of their tap water.

In conclusion, the goal should be to provide safe drinking water for all. Consumer Reports’ study highlights the need for better filtration systems, stringent regulations, and improved public perception of tap water. By striving for these goals, we can ensure that everyone has access to the safest drinking water brands and can confidently consume safe water.

FAQ Safest Bottled Water Consumer Reports

Is bottled water safer than tap water?

Consumer Reports’ study found that bottled water often contains contaminants such as PFAS, arsenic, and lead. Tap water in the US is regulated and subject to testing and compliance with safety standards.

What are PFAS and why are they a health concern?

PFAS, also known as “forever chemicals,” are a group of chemicals linked to health problems such as cancer and learning delays in children. They can seep into water sources and do not easily break down in the environment.

How is the bottled water industry regulated?

While tap water is regulated under the Safe Drinking Water Act, bottled water is regulated by the FDA, which has limited oversight and staff resources. The FDA allows bottlers to fill bottles with tap water, which may or may not be treated.

Are there contaminants in bottled water?

Studies have found contaminants in bottled water, including bacteria, chemical pollutants, and regulated carcinogens. Some of these contaminants have been linked to health effects, including cancer.

What is the environmental impact of bottled water?

Bottled water contributes to plastic pollution and waste. Most PET plastic bottles are not recycled, and the manufacturing process requires a significant amount of energy, water, and oil resources.

Is filtering tap water a safer alternative?

Filtering tap water can remove contaminants and improve its quality. Different types of filters, such as activated carbon and reverse osmosis, can be used to remove specific pollutants.

Why is investing in drinking water infrastructure important?

Upgrading filtration systems and addressing issues like lead pipes can help ensure the quality of tap water. This investment would improve public health and reduce reliance on bottled water.

How does public perception affect consumer choices?

Many consumers perceive bottled water to be safer and higher quality than tap water. However, raising awareness about the safety of tap water and promoting the use of water filters can help consumers make informed choices.

What is the safest drinking water brand?

Consumer Reports’ study highlights the presence of contaminants in many bottled water brands. Filtering tap water and investing in drinking water infrastructure are essential steps in providing safe and clean drinking water for all.

Source Links